CNIL Asks Senders and Email Providers for Feedback on Its Tracking Pixel Rules
France's CNIL is collecting feedback until 3 December 2026 on its recommendation on email tracking pixels, from senders and their technical providers, with figures on costs and measurement.

France's data protection authority, the CNIL, opened a call for feedback on 20 November 2026 on its recommendation on tracking pixels in emails. Seven months after the rules took effect, the regulator wants to hear from the companies that send email and from the technical providers behind them: what the recommendation changed, what it cost, and what replaced open tracking where consent is now required. Answers are accepted until Thursday 3 December 2026, through an online form.
The request is short, but it matters for anyone who sends to French recipients. It is the first time the CNIL asks the market to report on how the pixel rules work in practice, and the CNIL has already said it will check compliance with the recommendation during its future inspections.
Key facts
- Announced: 20 November 2026, on the CNIL website
- Deadline: feedback accepted until Thursday 3 December 2026
- Who can answer: private companies that send email and the technical providers they use; entities of the same group are asked to send one combined answer
- Channel: the CNIL's online consultation form, no email address is given
- Topics: effectiveness for people, difficulties, good practices, compliance costs, changes in audience measurement and personalisation, alternative solutions
- Background: recommendation adopted by deliberation n° 2026-042 of 12 March 2026 and published on 14 April 2026
What the CNIL is asking
The CNIL describes the exercise as a first return on experience. It asks whether the recommendation actually protects the people who receive email, which difficulties senders and providers ran into, and which good practices emerged while they adapted. It also wants to measure the concrete effects of the rules: the cost of compliance, how audience measurement and personalisation practices have changed, and which alternative solutions the market has built.
The regulator asks for precise and concrete answers, with figures wherever possible, and singles out the economic sustainability of email programmes as a point where numbers are especially welcome. The page does not publish a list of questions: the questions sit in the form itself. Organisations that belong to the same group are asked to pool their answers rather than send several.
What the recommendation requires
The recommendation on tracking pixels in emails applies to every public or private organisation that sends email containing tracking pixels, and to the technical providers they rely on. It complements the EDPB guidelines 2/2023 on the technical scope of the ePrivacy rules and the CNIL's own recommendation on cookies. The CNIL adopted it after a public consultation launched in June 2025 and closed on 24 July 2025, and justified it by a growing number of complaints, describing the inbox as a personal space meant for private content.
The CNIL lists three common uses of pixels: personalising messages according to the recipient's interests, measuring audience, and improving deliverability. The recommendation sets out when consent is required, how it must be obtained so that it is informed and free, how withdrawal must work to be effective, and how consent must be proven.
One exemption from consent was kept in the final text: individual deliverability measurement for emails linked to a service the recipient asked for. According to the CNIL, that covers transactional messages such as account alerts, shipping notices, order confirmations and invoices, password resets and security or data breach alerts, as well as emails the recipient consented to receive. Its purpose is to spot recipients who no longer open messages so that senders can remove inactive contacts. The CNIL insists that this tracking must be limited to what is strictly necessary and may only be used to measure deliverability.
For addresses collected before the recommendation was published, the CNIL set a lighter regime: within three months, senders had to clearly inform recipients that pixels are used, so that they can object easily. New contacts fall under the full recommendation.
Why this feedback round matters
Open tracking sits at the centre of how most email programmes judge engagement, clean their lists and run automation. A rule that makes part of that tracking depend on consent touches reporting, segmentation and sunset policies at once. The CNIL is now asking the people who live with those effects to document them, and it explicitly wants figures. Senders that have seen open data shrink, have moved to click or conversion metrics, or have struggled to separate exempt deliverability tracking from marketing analytics have a direct channel to say so before the regulator draws its own conclusions.
The call for feedback does not change the rules. The recommendation stays in force while the CNIL collects answers, and inspections can still check it.
What it means for senders
What changes
The CNIL is collecting feedback until 3 December 2026 on how its email tracking pixel rules work in practice, including their cost and their effect on audience measurement. The rules themselves stay unchanged and in force.
Who is affected
Companies that send marketing or transactional email to recipients in France, and the ESPs, sending platforms and analytics vendors that place or process tracking pixels for them.
When
The form is open now and closes on Thursday 3 December 2026. The recommendation has applied since its publication on 14 April 2026, and the CNIL plans to check it in future inspections.
Action checklist
- Decide whether to answer before 3 December 2026, and coordinate one combined answer if several entities of your group send email.
- Gather figures first: the share of opens you still measure, the cost of the changes, and any effect on revenue or list hygiene.
- Map your pixels by purpose so that deliverability tracking on transactional or consented email is separated from marketing analytics and personalisation.
- Check how consent to tracking is collected and withdrawn in your forms and preference centre, and keep proof of it.
- Ask your ESP which tracking options it offers per recipient or per message type, and whether it plans to answer the CNIL itself.
- Review your sunset policy if it relies on opens, so that inactive contacts can still be identified within the limits of the exemption.
Sources
- CNIL: Pixels de suivi dans les courriels, la CNIL sollicite un premier retour d'expérience sur sa recommandation, 20 November 2026 (primary source)
- CNIL: online feedback form on tracking pixels
- CNIL: recommendation on tracking pixels in emails, 14 April 2026
Related on SMTPedia
SMTPedia News follows our editorial standards. Spotted an error? See how we correct it.
Get SMTPedia news first on Google
Add us as a preferred source to see our stories in Top Stories and Discover.
Add as preferred sourceUseful story?
SMTPedia news is free and independent. A coffee helps us keep covering what changes for senders.
Buy SMTPedia a coffeeNewsletter